Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

Debt Management Plans: Your Path to Financial Freedom | Compare Agencies

wallet, money, credit card-2125548.jpg

Discover how debt management plans can help you pay off credit card debt over 3 to 5 years. Compare nonprofit credit counseling agencies and find the best fit for your financial situation.

Questions Answered in this Article

Q1: What is a debt management plan (DMP)?
A1: A debt management plan (DMP) is a structured approach to paying off debts, typically from credit cards, over three to five years. Multiple debts are consolidated into a single monthly payment, with reduced interest rates negotiated with creditors.

Q2: What are the pros of a debt management plan?
A2: Pros of a debt management plan include: a significant reduction in interest rates, faster debt payoff compared to individual efforts, and consolidation of multiple debts into one manageable payment.

Q3: What are the cons of a debt management plan?
A3: Cons of a debt management plan include: applicability primarily to credit card debt, limitations on credit card use and new credit lines, and the risk of derailing the plan and losing interest rate cuts if payments are missed.

Q4: When is a debt management plan suitable for individuals?
A4: A debt management plan might be suitable if an individual’s unsecured debt (e.g., credit card balances) is between 15% and 39% of their annual income, they have a stable income to pay off the debt within five years with lower interest rates, and they can manage without opening new credit lines during the plan.

Q5: What are the alternatives to debt management plans?
A5: Alternatives to debt management plans include: utilizing a DIY approach for debts below 15% of annual income, considering a debt consolidation loan for lower interest rates and credit line control, or opting for bankruptcy if debt exceeds 40% of annual revenue with no viable repayment plan.

Debt Management Plans: A Solution to Overwhelming Debt

Are you experiencing the weight of your financial obligations? A remedy to consider is a debt management plan, which can provide a structured approach to resolving your debts.

A debt management plan (DMP) offers a practical route to pay off outstanding debts, often from credit card usage, typically spanning three to five years. A DMP consolidates multiple debts into a single monthly payment, accompanied by lowered interest rates negotiated with creditors. In exchange for these concessions, you commit to a payment schedule typically spanning three to five years. It’s important to note that interest rate reductions adhere to standardized guidelines set by credit counseling agencies based on your creditors’ directives and your financial capacity.

Below, we present a comparative overview of debt management plans available through several prominent nonprofit credit counseling agencies.

More: Negotiating Credit Card Debt: Lowering Costs and Settlement Strategies

AgencyAvailabilityAverage Fees
ACCCAvailable in 50 states$39 startup fee
$23 monthly fee
CambridgeNationwide (phone & online)$35 startup fee
$30 monthly fee
CESI (Consumer Education Services Inc)Available in all 50 states$37 startup fee
& Puerto Rico$25 monthly fee
GreenPathAvailable in all 50 states$50 startup fee
$75 monthly fee
Money Management InternationalAvailable in 50 states$33 startup fee
$24 monthly fee

Pros and Cons of Debt Management Plans


  1. Significant reduction in interest rates, often by 50% or more.
  2. Accelerates debt repayment compared to individual efforts.
  3. Consolidates multiple debts into one manageable payment.


  1. Primarily applicable to credit card debt; ineligible for student loans, medical expenses, or tax liabilities.
  2. Requires a three to five-year commitment, during which new credit card use and credit applications are typically restricted.
  3. Deviating from the payment plan can jeopardize progress and eliminate interest rate reductions.

Is a Debt Management Plan Right for You?

DMPs aren’t universally suitable. Depending on the agency, only 10% to 20% of clients opt for this debt relief avenue. Of those who do, completion rates range between 50% and 70%, contingent on the year and reporting methods of the agency.

A DMP might be suitable if:

  1. Your unsecured debt, such as credit card balances, falls between 15% and 39% of your yearly income.
  2. You possess a stable income and believe your debt can be settled within five years with lower interest rates.
  3. You can manage without accessing new credit lines during the DMP.

More: Managing and Repaying Your Buy Now, Pay Later Debts: A Guide

Alternatives to Debt Management Plans

DMPs aren’t always the optimal solution for debt relief. Debts stemming from student loans and medical bills are generally ineligible. Alternative strategies include:

  1. For debt below 15% of your annual income, consider a DIY approach using the debt avalanche or debt snowball method.
  2. A debt consolidation loan, if creditworthy, can combine debts at a reduced interest rate, granting control over repayment duration and credit line accessibility.
  3. Bankruptcy might be preferable if debt surpasses 40% of your yearly income with no viable repayment path within five years. This rapid debt relief mechanism offers a fresh financial start, with credit scores potentially rebounding in as little as six months.

More: Understanding Balance Transfers: How They Work and Whether They’re Right for You

Initiating Your Debt Management Journey

If a DMP seems fitting for your debt relief needs, begin by selecting a credit counseling agency. Factors to assess include:

  1. Certification and Accreditation: Opt for an agency affiliated with the National Foundation for Credit Counseling or the Financial Counseling Association of America, ensuring independent accreditation and standardized counselor quality.
  2. Accessibility: Determine your preferred mode of service delivery: phone, in-person, or online.
  3. Cost: Fees differ by agency, location, and financial status. Before enrolling, verify monthly debt payments and associated fees.


  • Introduction to Debt Management Plans (DMPs) as a solution to overwhelming debt.
  • Explanation of DMPs: Structured approach to pay off credit card debts over 3 to 5 years.
  • DMPs consolidate multiple debts into one monthly payment with negotiated lower interest rates.
  • Pros of DMPs: Significant interest rate reduction, faster debt payoff, and simplified payment management.
  • Cons of DMPs: Limited applicability to credit card debt, new credit use restrictions, and missed payment risks.
  • Considerations for DMP suitability: Unsecured debt between 15% and 39% of annual income, stable income, and willingness to avoid new credit lines.
  • Alternative debt relief options: DIY methods for low debt ratios, debt consolidation loans for manageable rates, and bankruptcy for high debt levels.
  • Overview of nonprofit credit counseling agencies offering DMPs: ACCC, Cambridge, CESI, GreenPath, and Money Management International.
  • Comparison of agency availability, startup fees, and monthly fees for DMPs.
  • Importance of agency certification and accreditation from reputable organizations.
  • Factors to consider: Service accessibility (phone, in-person, online) and cost evaluation before enrollment.
  • Conclusion: Choosing the right debt relief approach based on personal financial circumstances and goals.
Don't miss out!

Sign up to our mailing list to get updates on new products and content as they arrive.